In Cliffhangers, Nicholas arrived and Beast Boy asked him what's up. Nicholas took this literally and said that the sky was up. During the challenge, Nicholas jumped off the cliff with ease, only to hit a bouy. After the challenge, when his team were discussing who to vote off, he said that he thought they lost because they had more ninja. This caused the ninja to gasp and for Sasuke and Sakura to go up to him, with Sakura picking him up by the collar. He explained that his grandfather would tell him stories of how he would defeat hundreds of ninja, even though he was not that strong, making Nicholas believe that ninja were weak. This angered the ninja even more and they began to attack him, but Hinata stopped them, saying he didn't mean it, but Nicholas denied this and said he was serious. At the bonfire ceremony, Nicholas became the first person voted off, due to his insults to the ninja.